Signature reports

Divided by Design

“Divided by Design” uncovers the profound impacts of transportation decisions on socio-economic and environmental landscapes, revealing a legacy of division that continues to affect marginalized neighborhoods.

Good Intentions Aren't Enough

Simply putting new people with better intentions at the helm of our transportation apparatus has failed to repair past mistakes or stop producing the same old inequalities. While they often use more enlightened language, little in the program has fundamentally changed so the outcomes haven’t changed much either.

It’s sobering to read about our sordid history of transportation planning and investment in America in Part I. Learning that history is vital, and should be required reading for anyone involved in transportation today. But we can’t stop there. We must also understand how our actions today still cause harm, especially to low income and Black and Brown communities.

We’re sympathetic to the many well- intentioned policymakers, transportation planners, and engineers working today who find that history just as appalling and strive to depart from the practices of the past.

We understand that many who have their hands on the levers of control today are not intending the same results as their forebears, many of whom intentionally sought to harm, divide, and displace people solely because of the color of their skin or size of their wallets. But as Part II shows at length, good intent is not powerful enough to override a system that has institutionalized and internalized values that still prioritize certain people over others and one type of travel over everything else.

Using the same tools as decades past and hoping for different results is a losing battle.

The end result is the same old outcomes of yesterday. At some point, tolerating the same results gives rise to culpability.

If we’re ever going to truly move past the disgraceful history of our highway program, we have to discard the systems of the past.

Systems created to separate and segregate cannot help us restore and renew. Models and measures designed to move vehicles above all else cannot be used to prioritize people and places. Our scales don’t need rebalancing, they need replacing,

The recommendations in Part III, while substantial, are not exhaustive. Countless other organizations and advocates have important ideas about what’s necessary to truly do away with our historic approach to transportation and build a new system from the ground up. But those four broad areas are a good place to start.

We hope that those on the inside, from members of Congress down to local transportation planners, will work together to create new tools and approaches to reconnect and restore what has been divided by design.

Download Divided by Design 2023

Download Report
img
logo
1350 I St NW Suite 425 Washington, DC 20005
info@smartgrowthamerica.org

Subscribe to our newsletter

Livable places. Healthy people. Shared prosperity.

© 2025 Smart Growth America. All rights reserved

Accessibility